For The Media: Year’s End Reflections

Here’s hoping all of you have had happy and healthy holidays. More to the point, here’s hoping you’ve had very Merry Christmases. There, I said it.

I think as media, we too often over-react and understate because we’re too easily intimidated by the political correctness police who remain religiously on the beat. As if Christmas were nothing more than shopping sprees, crèche crises and seasonal opportunities to celebrate the separation of church and state. As if Christmas had no historical back story. As if by its very mention, we de facto slight and affront certain societal segments. Humbug.

And did I mention that I hoped you had a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year?

And while we’re taking the media to task, in effect, let’s just formulate some more media conversation into a kind of New Year’s resolutions’ format. Would that the media:

* Double down on shedding light–not heat–on the polarizing issues of these fractious days for America.

* No longer act as a publicity accomplice for: Duck Dynasty, Miley Cyrus, anyone named Kardashian, Paula Deen, Justin Bieber, Lady Gaga, Ted Cruz, Donald Trump, Snookie, Hulk Hogan, Sarah Palin, Bubba the Love Sponge, Kanye West, Charlie Sheen and Dennis Rodman. And speaking of Rodman, too bad his most recent visit to North Korea didn’t result in a longer stay and serious chillin’ time with Kim Jong-un. Perhaps family executions are hard on a bromance.

* No longer treat movie sequels, especially those based on comic books and video games, as serious fare worthy of review space comparable to, say, Philomena.

* Be ever more vigilant about polls in the news. They can influence–not just gauge–public opinion, and too many are push polls. The reading public has no idea of all the sampling variables as well as key contextual elements in how questions are framed or prefaced. And think long and hard about doing your own poll. Are you reporting the news–or making it?

* Re-think the uber hype approach, especially at the local TV-network-affiliate level, in covering the weather. Could we, for example, eliminate those melodramatic, Armageddon-like weather teases that don’t actually warrant details until it’s weather’s slotted time before sports?

And if you want meteorological cred beyond a clever name for your customized radar-tracker, tell your weather guy that wearing suspenders gives a contrived, show-bizzy look.

* Stop referring to the Affordable Care Act, no matter its amateur-hour roll-out and Rube Goldberg construction, as “Obamacare.” That was a politically partisan tag line originally aimed at defaming the ACA. It’s still unconscionably careless for mainstream media to use “Obamacare” as a synonym for the ACA.

And that, ironically, goes for the president too, who has used it in a self-effacing attempt to defuse it. It didn’t, to say the least, work. He would have been better off with “Romneycare II.”

Interestingly–but not surprisingly–polls have shown that the Affordable Care Act consistently gets higher approval ratings than “Obamacare.” That’s disturbing–but not at all shocking, which is cause for further anxiety.

* End the double standard when it comes to Lee Harvey Oswald. The mainstream media bends over backwards to accord the likes of Tampa’s Dontae Morris, Boston’s Dzhokhar Tsarnaev and Aurora, Colo.’s James Holmes the technical benefit of the legal doubt by referring to them as “suspects” before they are tried and convicted for what they “allegedly” did. Indeed, that is fair and proper, even though there were witnesses and video evidence. The verdict lies with the jury, not the media.

But why persist in referring to Oswald as President John F. Kennedy’s assassin–without qualifier–when he was never accorded the right to live long enough to have a trial? Let alone be convicted. Let alone explain his involvement in the beyond-byzantine world of Cold War, government-agency intrigues.

Moreover, any cursory look at how that investigation was handled would yield a classic example of tainted, cherry-picked and compromised evidence. What chain-of-evidence custody? An Oswald conviction would have been problematic.

Whatever the rationale–and I suspect ignorance, the passage of time and hypersensitivity to being duped by “conspiracy nuts” are key components–continued absence of “alleged” before Oswald as assassin, lone or otherwise, remains a breach of journalistic ethics.

* End its trafficking in clichés–starting with whoever is dubbed a “rock star” to whoever received a “wake-up call” to whoever “brought their A-game” to whoever “reinvented the wheel” to whoever determined “it’s not rocket science.”

But I say that, of course, with all due respect because at the end of the day–by virtue of thinking outside the box–we can all see that paradigms do shift and some writers have absolutely no shame when it comes to a rhetorical exit strategy.

Poll Skeptic

When it comes to polls, put me down for skeptic who could easily morph into cynic. There are too many polls, such that they can also become a making-the-news industry. Too many are de facto push polls that get away with not informing the public about all their sampling details and all the contextual ways questions can be asked.

Not coincidentally, this just in: “Nelson No Match For Crist, Poll Shows.”

That was a recent Tampa Bay Times headline. It was prompted by a gubernatorial poll conducted a few weeks back by Fabrizio McLaughlin & Associates. It found that if recent Democratic convert Charlie Crist were to face primary opposition from U.S. Senator Bill Nelson, it would be no contest. Crist, in fact, already has a healthy, double-digit lead.

And who knows, maybe such results help pre-empt Nelson momentum and help assure a Scott-Crist face-off, even if the former governor runs into negative-publicity head winds later next year. And who knows, perhaps the Scott campaign has reason to prefer candidate Crist, whose lead over Scott has been trimmed of late, to Nelson. And who knows, the fact that Fabrizio McLaughlin is Scott’s pollster could be worth noting.

Quoteworthy

* “Marxist ideology is wrong. But I have met many Marxists in my life who are good people. … There is nothing in the (November apostolic) exhortation that cannot be found in the social doctrine of the church.”–Pope Francis.

* “We hold that the State of New Mexico is constitutionally required to allow same-gender couples to marry and must extend to them the rights, protections and responsibilities that derive from civil marriage under New Mexico law.”–New Mexico Supreme Court Justice Edward L. Chavez.

* “Literally, there are people choosing, ‘Do I want to go work for General Motors and design vehicles, or do I want to go do movies?’ It’s the same talent.”–Mary Barra, newly named CEO of General Motors Co.

* “We try to leave the politics out in the hallway when we make these decisions. … Are you going to allow your people to have additional Medicaid money that comes at no cost to us, or aren’t you? “–Jack Dalrymple, the Republican governor of North Dakota.

* “If we had a conservative majority in the Senate, Republicans wouldn’t need to compromise our principles to avoid another government shutdown.”–Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla.

* “Senator Rubio strikes me as a person not only highly attuned to criticisms of him from the base, but overly reactive to them, adjusting and responding moment by moment.”–Peter Wehner, Commentary.

* “Senator Rubio spent time looking at all the (federal health care) options and decided to enroll through the D.C. exchange for coverage for him and his family. Senator Rubio is following the law, even though he opposes it.”–Rubio spokeswoman Brooke Sammon.

* “Thank you, Sen. Rubio, for your endorsement of the new health care law.”–Democratic gubernatorial candidate Charlie Crist.

* “I love what I do and I’m going to return to what I do, what you sent me to do in Washington, D.C.”–U.S. Rep. Trey Radel, R-Fort Myers, who was busted buying cocaine from an undercover officer in Washington last month.

* “If we don’t find a cure soon, we won’t be growing oranges in Florida much longer.”–Sen. Bill Nelson, D-Fla., on the federal government’s involvement in the fight against citrus greening disease.

* “This also highlights the fact that we’ve got to take another step in modernizing the relationship between the United States and Cuba. We have got to move on from this Cold War policy that does not encourage greater engagement and dialogue. It is time now.”–U.S. Rep. Kathy Castor, D-Tampa, on the announcement of the 11th weekly flight from TIA to Cuba.

* “It’s exciting that this early on, before the flights even launch, that Copa is already having to move to bigger planes to accommodate the demand.”–TIA spokeswoman Emily Nipps on passenger demand exceeding expectations for Copa Airlines new TIA-to-Panama City, Panama route.

* “We are not interested in consolidation.”–Hillsborough County Commissioner Sandra Murman, who sits on the Tampa Port Authority board, on speculation about the future plans of the Port of Tampa and Port Manatee.

* “It’s been a helluva year. A lot more coming.”–Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn.

* “If this constrained road system is not addressed, then the job site is going to become irrelevant.”–Hillsborough County Economic Development Director Ron Barton.

* “There’s definitely a focus by this administration on inequality and on poverty, so that’s really important to us back at home.”–St. Petersburg Mayor-elect Rick Kriseman, who was among a group of newly elected mayors who met with President Barack Obama at the White House.

* “The truth is this flood insurance problem is affecting people with very modest incomes, and nobody can really prove otherwise. What’s going on in Congress now is just not right.”–Pam Dubov, Pinellas County property appraiser, on the impact of the Biggert-Waters Flood Insurance Reform Act of 2012.

* “We like being here.”–Iowa football coach Kirk Ferentz, whose Hawkeyes will play in the Outback Bowl, noting that the on-campus temperature back in Iowa City was minus-5 degrees the day he was in Tampa.

* “We’re a good team without Stammer. Maybe when Stammer comes back, we can be a great team.”–Tampa Bay Lightning coach Jon Cooper on the absence of Stephen Stamkos, out with a broken leg since Nov. 11.

Quoteworthy

* “How do we connect the dots? There is no other way that we know of to connect the dots. … Taking these programs off the table is absolutely not the thing to do.”–National Security Agency Chief Gen. Keith Alexander in pleading for the retention of the NSA’s bulk-collection (global phone and Internet records) programs.

* “Marxist ideology is wrong. But I have met many Marxists in my life who are good people. … There is nothing in the (November apostolic) exhortation that cannot be found in the social doctrine of the church.”–Pope Francis.

* “Americans of all persuasions desperately need a rebirth of a strong, two-party Washington. And an end to the dysfunction that is Hate City. That means America needs Republican leaders who will embrace the Mandela leadership credo the world celebrated (last) week, and put their country’s prosperity ahead of their own. That’s not socialism. It’s patriotism.”–Martin Schram, McClatchy-Tribune News Service.

* “Literally, there are people choosing, ‘Do I want to go work for General Motors and design vehicles, or do I want to go do movies?’ It’s the same talent.”–Mary Barra, newly named CEO of General Motors Co.

* “We try to leave the politics out in the hallway when we make these decisions. … Are you going to allow your people to have additional Medicaid money that comes at no cost to us, or aren’t you? “–Jack Dalrymple, the Republican governor of North Dakota.

* “If we had a conservative majority in the Senate, Republicans wouldn’t need to compromise our principles to avoid another government shutdown.”–Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla.

* “Senator Rubio strikes me as a person not only highly attuned to criticisms of him from the base, but overly reactive to them, adjusting and responding moment by moment.”–Peter Wehner, Commentary.

* “Senator Rubio spent time looking at all the (federal health care) options and decided to enroll through the D.C. exchange for coverage for him and his family. Senator Rubio is following the law, even though he opposes it.”–Rubio spokeswoman Brooke Sammon.

* “Thank you, Sen. Rubio, for your endorsement of the new health care law.”–Democratic gubernatorial candidate Charlie Crist.

* “Rick Scott wanted voters to think he had changed his stripes, but all he did was prove that he is willing to say anything to win re-election.”–Democratic National Committee Chairwoman Debbie Wasserman Schultz (D-Fla.).

* “While some of the decrease in November can be attributed to seasonality, the depth and breadth of the decrease provides strong evidence that we are entering the ninth inning of this foreclosure crisis with the outcome all but guaranteed.”–RealtyTrac Vice President Daren Blomquist on the national foreclosure scene, including the Tampa Bay area where foreclosure activity fell by 29 percent last month.

* “If we don’t find a cure soon, we won’t be growing oranges in Florida much longer.”–Sen. Bill Nelson, D-Fla., on the federal government’s involvement in the fight against citrus greening disease.

* “This also highlights the fact that we’ve got to take another step in modernizing the relationship between the United States and Cuba. We have got to move on from this Cold War policy that does not encourage greater engagement and dialogue. It is time now.”–U.S. Rep. Kathy Castor, D-Tampa, on the announcement of the 11th weekly flight from TIA to Cuba.

* “It’s exciting that this early on, before the flights even launch, that Copa is already having to move to bigger planes to accommodate the demand.”–TIA spokeswoman Emily Nipps on passenger demand exceeding expectations for Copa Airlines new TIA-to-Panama City, Panama route.

* ” This is just fantastic for the Tampa Bay area. This is so exciting. This is huge.”–Tampa Bay Bucs co-chairman Bryan Glazer on news that Tampa was selected to host the 2017 College Football Playoff National Championship game.

* “If this constrained road system is not addressed, then the job site is going to become irrelevant.”–Hillsborough County Economic Development Director Ron Barton.

* “There’s definitely a focus by this administration on inequality and on poverty, so that’s really important to us back at home.”–St. Petersburg Mayor-elect Rick Kriseman, who was among a group of newly elected mayors who met with President Barack Obama at the White House.

* “The truth is this flood insurance problem is affecting people with very modest incomes, and nobody can really prove otherwise. What’s going on in Congress now is just not right.”–Pam Dubov, Pinellas County property appraiser, on the impact of the Biggert-Waters Flood Insurance Reform Act of 2012.

* “We like being here.”–Iowa football coach Kirk Ferentz, whose Hawkeyes will play in the Outback Bowl, noting that the on-campus temperature back in Iowa City was minus-5 degrees the day he was in Tampa.

POTY Problem

Time magazine marketing includes its annual “Person of the Year” cover story and the drumbeat countdown that features the “finalists.” And, no, the POTY designation is not meant to mean “best” or most “popular” person, but recognition of someone with major impact–including politics, business and culture. But, still, I’m old-school enough to not like seeing Pope Francis on the same list, any list, with Miley Cyrus and Bashar al-Assad.

“Cancelled” Is Canceled

Cancel this spelling: “cancelled.”

This time of year it’s hard to miss, whether you’re flying somewhere or just privy to ubiquitous news stories about what’s in store for the flying public. Count on seeing photo and video shots of airline boards showing scheduled flights that are often canceled or all-too-often “cancelled.” Which is it?

As a public service–and a pet peeve about those who should know better–here’s the word right from my old “Associated Press Stylebook and Libel Manual,” although a middle-school textbook should cover it as well. When to double that last consonant or not?

If the stress in pronunciation is on the second syllable, double that final consonant. Hence: con trol’ becomes controlled.

But if the stress is on the first syllable, do not double the consonant. Don’t you dare. Hence: can’ cel becomes CANCELED.

Quoteworthy

* “People can take everything from you. I lost my family, the chance to see my children grow up, the best years of my life. They can take everything except your mind and your heart. Those things I decided not to give away …”–Nelson Mandela.

* “The role of the Internet was overrated in Egypt and Tunisia. But it is underrated in the Gulf, where, in these more closed societies, Facebook, Twitter and YouTube are providing vast uncontrolled spaces for men and women to talk to each other–and back at their leaders. … Saudi Arabia alone produces almost half of all tweets in the Arab world and is among the most Twitter- and YouTube-active nations in the world.”–Thomas L. Friedman, New York Times.

* “Technology and globalization are driving the good deals American consumers are getting this holiday season. But the same forces are keeping wages down, and are even on the verge of eliminating many of the low-wage retail and related service jobs many Americans now need to make ends meet.”–Robert Reich, former secretary of labor in the Clinton administration.

* “When did fast-food restaurants become the fulcrum for social engineering?”–Dan Fitzpatrick, CEO of Quality Dining Inc., which owns hundreds of fast-food franchises, including Burger Kings.

* “A large percentage of Florida’s high school graduates are finding the transition into higher education increasingly difficult. In fact, too many students still leave high school unprepared to perform work at the college level. … Higher education should be to polish, enhance and enable graduates to live meaningful lives. Time spent remediating is time lost.”–Ed Moore, president and CEO of the Independent Colleges & Universities of Florida.

* “Despite our general preference for capitalism, our support for sports is essentially socialist, with local and state governments providing enormous support for professional teams.”–Gary Gutting, professor of philosophy, University of Notre Dame.

* “Not long ago, most intelligent television talk was not about politics. … Now most TV and radio talk is minute political analysis, while talk of culture has shriveled. This change is driven by people who, absent other attachments, have fallen upon partisanship to give them a sense of righteousness and belonging. This emotional addiction can lead to auto-hysteria.”–David Brooks, New York Times.

* “Some of us are fine with faith so long as it speaks in platitudinous generalities or offers a weapon to clobber gay people with, but scream bloody murder when it imposes specific demands on their personal conscience–or wallet.”–Leonard Pitts, Miami Herald.

* “We’re the Sunshine State, and we’re hardly doing any solar energy production. We should be the global leader in solar energy.”–Democratic gubernatorial candidate Charlie Crist.

* “When a company is creating its own jobs, you don’t get a lot of (gubernatorial) podium moments.”–Tom O’Neal, executive director of GrowFl, UCF’s economic development institute.

* “The flights are exceeding expectations.”–TIA CEO Joe Lopano on early demand for Copa Airline’s nonstop flights between Tampa and Panama City, Panama, that begin this month.

* “The bottom line is it’s got to be a local effort. The state is ready and willing to step up and see what we can do. But it’s not going to be until everyone here comes together  and says we do or don’t want (cruise ships).”–Richard Biter, Florida Department of Transportation’s assistant secretary for intermodal systems development, on how the Bay Area’s decides to address scenarios involving future mega cruise ships and a Sunshine Skyway Bridge that won’t have enough clearance.

* “If I had my way, we wouldn’t have any exceptions (for transfers). Our job is to educate students. We are not a farm team for colleges.”–Carol Kurdell, Hillsborough County School Board chairwoman.

* “We should be careful when applying a cost-benefit analysis when the safety of our children is involved; however, using a single incident involving a nine-year-old with a derringer to justify a $4.5 million annual expenditure for additional elementary schools SROs (school resource officers) is simply illogical.”–Mike Pheneger, president of the American Civil Liberties Union of Florida.

* “There’s no way around it: We have an insatiable appetite for giving out proclamations.”–Hillsborough County Commissioner Ken Hagan.

Blasphemy, The Musical, Scores Big

It came. We saw. It conquered.

It’s been a couple of weeks now that my wife and I were part of a very receptive, very packed Straz Center to see the controversial, award-winning musical, “The Book of Mormon.” Ours was not an anomalous experience. From book and music to set design and choreography, there was much to appreciate and admire. The blockbuster hit had a very successful, pre-holiday run.

“It’s a terrific show for Tampa to get,” assessed Paul Bilyeu, the Straz’s senior director of communications. “And if we didn’t get it, it would be noted.”

Indeed, it would not have looked good if internationally recognized, Tony Award fare didn’t play well in this market–one with such a world-class facility. Tampa isn’t New York, but neither is it New Port Richey.

Somewhat to my surprise–given that I often feel like an alien in pop culture–I liked the “The Book of Mormon” more than I expected. It worked on several levels–enough, let’s be honest, to transcend periodic forays into questionable taste and sophomoric humor.

This is not “The Book of World Records” by Guinness, “The Book of Face” by Zuckerberg or the “Book of Love” by the Monotones. This is “The Book of Mormon” by “South Park” creators, a sacrilegious send-up of a, let’s be honest again, quirky religion’s  holy book. And Trey Parker and Matt Stone took no prisoners–even when they should have.

Bottom line: Thank you, wholly vulnerable Mormon religion.

Parody material to die for is a theatrical godsend. We all have doorbells. We remember the Romney campaign “cult” disclaimers. The polygamy reminders. Many of us still have our “Mad Magazine” side. We get it.

Other religions have, for example, Jesus of Nazareth or Muhammad of Medina as their deified prophets. The Mormons have Joe Smith of upstate New York. And the hits keep coming from there. From nerdy, teenaged missionaries presuming to explain much of anything to other cultures, especially African ones, to biblical back stories that might as well have Hobbits in the mix.

Plus, I grew up a George Carlin Catholic. I know dogmatic satire material when I see it.

And, of course, thank you, musical comedy.

Blasphemies–at least this side of Sharia law–set to song, dance and farce don’t seem so blasphemous. Think: “Life of Brian,” (“blessed are the cheese makers”) or “Jesus Christ Superstar” (“Prove to me that you’re no fool, walk across my swimming pool”) or “The Producers” (“Spring Time for Hitler”). Hilarious. And in the case of Mel Brooks’ “Spring Time,” maybe even a device to defuse evil by reducing it to song and dance.

It might not seem fair, but well-done musical comedy is the perfect vehicle for the otherwise unacceptably outrageous. And making light of the holocaust, genital mutilation and AIDS–as well as flipping off God–arguably qualify. But, yes, they were also–wink, nod–plot-advancing devices.

To be sure, there were times when humor was “South Park” at its most crudely juvenile. We could have done without a cultural, sexual-deviancy spoof and a simulated sex act by Jeffrey Dahmer. Mercifully, the latter was in the diversion-filled, “Spooky Mormon Hell Dream” scene  and could be easily missed. Some things “South Parkers” just can’t resist–even when they should.

Probably the loudest laugh of the night was elicited from a line by one of the young missionary “elders,” who was reeling from revelatory life outside the Utah cocoon: “I can’t believe Jesus called me a dick.”

Actually, by then, it’s downright believable. Jesus had a case.

Benghazi Upshot

So, CBS suspended 60 Minutes correspondent Lara Logan and her producer over that red-flag bedecked, Benghazi-raid piece that couldn’t be verified. Anything else it wants to acknowledge? How about the uncanny occurrence of highly promoted, well-teased interviews with those who happen to have a book out the next day? That’s the modern equivalent of checkbook journalism.